Ahh here we go, rant time again! Or is it? Hmm, Not sure to be honest. I am currently trying out for replacements for the Firecrest, and am currently playing with the Benro FH100M2 and FH100M3. They are both basically the same, however the M2 version uses a screw in polariser, whilst the M3 version has a magnetic mount and a slightly different method of rotating it. I bought the M3 version after a week or so playing with the M2.

XT2B5347
XT2B5436

Lets look at the system overall . You get a nicely designed Aluminium frame with 3 Plastic slots (one more slot than the Firecrest), with some nice contrasting anodized knobs and catches. On one side is a retaining clip with locking screw, and on the other is a little gear wheel which can be moved from slot to slot by pulling. Why is that there you ask? Well, with this holder the filters don't go straight into the holder. No, they first get attached into a plastic frame which has a toothed rack down the sides which engage with the little pinion gear attached to the left hand knob. This is supposed to give you precise control over filter adjustments. Both feature rear mounted polarisers. On the M2, the polariser is rotated by a ring around the back of the holder, but the M3 has a little attachment screwed on which uses a miniature caterpillar track to rotate that same ring from the edge of the holder rather than the back. Both models have the polariser rotating around the outside of the lens mount by attaching it to a free spinning ring inside the holder. The method of attaching the polariser is different - the M2 uses a screw in arrangement of the same type as the Firecrest (the polarisers themselves are actually interchangeable should you need to replace one), whereas the M3 uses magnets.

XT2B5706
Magnetic rotating ring shown in the FH100M3 on the left, with the screw in ring of the FH100M2 on the right.

So first impressions - well it looks good. First impressions on use? Oh dear lord what a mess. I tried the M2 first, the first step being half an hour spent trying to engage the polariser threads with the holder. Not easy at all and this was nearly as far as I got before sending it back. I'm glad I persevered though, because now after a few on and offs in the field, the CPL screws in much easier. Next came the filters. These are again a bit of a faff initially, so I purchased extra frames, trying to take them in and out of a single frame is a recipe for damage at worst, and fingerprints all over the filter at best. Once they are all individually framed however, handling filters becomes a breeze, which is nice.

The little gear wheel for precision adjustments, however, leaves a lot to be desired. It has no lead in chamfer on the gear, so can take a lot of force to actually get it to engage in the teeth of the frame. This is complicated further by Benro having put a detent button which must be depressed every time you want to move slot. It's very easy to overshoot, or simply not engage in the frame at all. If you have just one filter in place it works OK, you can set the gear up once and leave it engaged, but with 3 filters in there you're in for some real awkward fun.

XT2B5366
There is not a lot of meat to grab on the CPL in the FH100M2
FH100M2 CPL Spanner
So they give you a tool to help! I preferred not using the tool though personally.
XT2B5714
You can avoid the entire procedure with the FH100M3, which simply drops in.
XT2B5343
Getting filters into frames is a messy business.
XT2B5373
Filters are locked in the frames by pushing the little blue toggle into the little detent, which closes the frame up around the filter.

Awkwardness potentially doesn't end there either because, like the Firecrest, step up rings are needed to fit lenses with threads less than 67mm. I have no idea what these manufacturers think they are achieving by designing this way, Step up rings in the field are a nightmare! The Firecrest at least was a multiple piece adaptor ring with the rotating section for the CPL, so you can understand wanting to keep production costs down by only making 3 sizes, however the Benro one is a single piece dumb affair, which is no more expensive to make than a step up ring! I will no doubt end up with several of the 82mm variants with step up rings permanently glued to them.

XT2B5359
The standard adaptor ring. This is the 82mm version, a 77mm is also supplied with the holder and they are available down to 67mm. Anything smaller you'll need to use Step Up Rings.
XT2B5382
77mm ring on Fuji XF 16-55mm f2.8. They are similar to Wide Angle adaptor rings sold for other systems, but have knurled edges. Poor engineering practice from a rotational point of view, but easy to attach/remove from the lens.
XT2B5377
Locating Catch (Red) and Locking Screw (Blue).
XT2B5425
Adjusting a single filter is reasonably easy...with multiple filters it becomes a chore.
XT2B5439
On the FH100M2 the polariser is adjusted by turning a ring, which is a little difficult to get at, especially so if wearing gloves.
XT2B5717
The FH100M3 by contrast moves the rotation mechanism outwards by putting in an idler gear turned by a rubber caterpillar track. Much more accessible

The biggest concern I have with all filter systems is light leaks, flare and reflections. As I touched on in part 1, the Lee type and it's clones are all really bad at this. The Firecrest uses covers which are effective, but as I found out, fragile and fiddly and ultimately not a lot of fun out in the field. The frames on the Benro system seem so far to have managed to do an equally good job as the Firecrest's covers, the only time I see flaring is shooting straight into the sun (and that's a product of the Resin Lee grads which won't go away no matter what you hold them with), shooting sideways on or with my back to the Sun did not manage to produce any flares, and I did try really hard.

XT2B5430
Trying to introduce flare into an image...it didn't work.

I am now having to make my mind up what to keep, if any. I have considered the Nisi V6, but I can see right away that I won't like the locking mechanism, or indeed the fact that there is zero flare protection. I am leaning towards keeping the FH100M3 simply for the magnetic polariser attachment. In 2 weeks of using the FH100M2 I got used to the awkward CPL rotating ring position, so if the caterpillar does break on the M3, I can always unscrew it and use it as the M2. That just leaves addressing the little pinion gear. I will probably take it apart and chamfer the pinion a little in the lathe, and may well do away with the detent button altogether. There may be a Part 3!

XT2B5434
XT2B5408
Whilst using this setup I was able to shoot...
Above Arthog
This!