Ah yes, the square filter system. Beloved by many, derided as outdated and redundant in the digital age by others. I'm firmly in Camp 1 - Filters are my friends. Or at least they would be, if I could actually find a decent system!
You see, there are many manufacturers of filters out there. Some have been on the market seemingly forever, and some filters really should have gone the way of the dodo by now but they keep clinging on. Why? Because (Unpopular opinion klaxon alert!) photographers on the whole wouldn't know quality if it ran up behind them and let off an air horn. I don't mean to be harsh about my brothers in arms, but seriously, take a look. Google any filter brand or system and you will find a plethora of blogs, reviews and video reviews extolling the virtues of System X from brand Y and why it's amazing - particularly I have noticed, if it has been CNC machined. Yes I'm going to digress on a rant here, because I'm an Engineer. I can spot a shoddy design or cheap manufacture because I'm in the game. Sadly photographers on the whole don't get it. As far as filter holders go if it's made of Aluminium and sprayed black it is instantly "Outstanding Build Quality", likewise filters made of glass.
OK I'm coming across all Gammony. Lets return to my filter journey so far. My first filters were Cokin P. These taught me how to use Graduated Neutral Density Filters, and for that I am grateful. I am not grateful for the colour casts though. So long Cokin. Next I tried Kood filters. OK here's nice I thought, Pretty neutral these. Shame they scratch if you so much as wave a microfibre cloth at them.
Next came the 100mm experiments - some fake Lee filters and an ebay holder. I didn't know they were fake until I tried them. They were ok as it happens, but were decidedly yellow. Oh well. They lasted until the CHinese holder fell apart on location, and I got rid.
Then came Lee's Sev5n or 75mm, system, an ideal companion set for my Fuji X gear. This went well on the whole, I even hacked my remaining Kood filters down to 75mm width. The real mcCoy Lee Graduated filters were near as damn it neutral, though the stoppers weren't and the holder system lets in a lot of extraneous light causing a real party of flare and ghosting. The holder can't be used on the 10-24mm either, although if you are prepared for some juggling you can hold a bare 75mm filter against the lens and use it that way, I did for a while but it quickly became tedious. So back to 100mm it was.
With me so far? Yes I know it's a bit boring but we're nearly there! So 100mm again and this time I'm going all out on research (see my point about reviews!). I tried a Hitech filter holder - it was junk. A big slab of Aluminium, yes it felt nice, but it was machined on the skew and scratched the very expensive Firecrest glass Grads I bought at the same time. That was done away with right handy. As, by the by, were the glass filters. Sorry here's another rant....
Firecrest glass filters are a joke! They claim to be multicoated - but what they have done is put the coatings between two layers of glass to protect it from being scratched off...at the same time completely negating any usefulness in the coatings at all. Good job Hitech. I didn't use them long. They were neutral, granted, but that's not a jot of use when every photo taken with them has a mirror image of the front of the lens like a watermark across it! I even went out of my way to get the ultra expensive Firecrest holder to go with them, and that will be the subject of rant No.3...
For those of you unfamiliar with the product, the FIrecret holder is a solid Aluminium lump (a lot like the normal Hitech holder) which fist on specific adapter rings for your camera that incorporate a free spinning front part which has gear teeth around the perimeter. Onto this is screwed a Polariser, not a normal one, a special one that is super thin and doesn't rotate. The holder then clips over the adapter ring in such a way that a little thumbwheel on one side engages with the gear teeth in the spinning portion of the adapter and rotates the polariser. You can then pop your grads in front of it and away you go shooting. The fun doesn't stop there - to control unwanted light and keep it of your filters, there is a rubberised top and bottom cover with inserts to suit the filters in use.
It all sounds great doesn't it? And up to now, this has been my favourite filter holder. Not that this should be construed as praise. Far from it, it's just the least shit of all the holders on the market.
So why do I hate it? Well it comes back to the whole photographers are not engineers thing again. It is an interesting design, that almost makes it. It falls down mainly on 1 thing - step up rings. It seems that these high end filters all want you to use step up rings rather than make available adapters that actually fit our lenses. They do make adapter rings in some sizes, but only down to 72mm. I also have 52, 58 and 62mm filter threads on my X gear. Step rings are just evil - anything fiddly is evil on location, particularly for landscapes where you're often out in adverse conditions and the last thing you want to be doing is assembling very fiddly bits of kit. Unfortunately, that's exactly what Hitech gives you.
Consider my 10-24mm. That has a dedicated lens ring, so that's not too bad. That is screwed onto the lens. OK so far. Then I want a CPL. OK I'll screw that really slim CPL into a freely rotating ring that is super awkward to grip. OK, that's 5 minutes spend trying to line up the threads, another 5 trying to get purchase on the thing to screw it in with my cold numb fingers. Now I clip the holder on, insert my Fixed ND in the back slot, then I insert the vented insert into each rubber cover, faff about getting them to clip in and then spend a few moments figuring out which way they go onto the holder (they have to go one way round or it won't fit). Now I finally slide in the grad, adjust the CPL and take the picture. And that's an easy lens, if it was a 55-200 I'd have to find the 82mm lens ring and then the 62-82mm step up ring and assemble them too. A right faff? you bet it is!
And what's worse, out on location the teeny tiny screw that holds the holder's spring clip mechanism on fell out! Luckily whilst it was in my hand so I didn't lose it but I would have been sorely miffed if it had vanished. Unfortunate? Yes, I am. That's probably why a short while later, whilst removing the rubberised covers, one snapped clean in half and sent the little vented cap off who knows where, I never found that. a Replacement set will set me back £40, so needless to say I haven't bothered.
That's where you find me. My Firecrest CPL has barely been used because it's too much trouble. The filter holder may as well be a cheap chinese one again as its trendy (and actually I'll admit quite good at it's job!) rubber cover is broken and lets in light. But it's not the end of the story, for in part 2 we shall examine what may be the Bee's Knees of filter systems - the new Benro FH100 system...




